Theirs, in our words
#34at 45%●●●○○2× h2 · 3× p · 3× fine · 49 words
Card two: LiverMD from 1MD Nutrition, graded B+, with the same three chips. A one-sentence summary grants truly absorbable ingredients, then lists three drawbacks: two capsules a day, amounts missing from the sales page, a higher full price.
Why it works. Present a credible runner-up, with its faults in the first sentence. candorcontrastspecificity
Why it sits here, and how it is written
The rival cards let the reader finish comparison shopping without leaving the page. Second place must look strong or the ranking looks rigged. The summary sits above the pros, so a skimmer takes away the markdown even if they read nothing else in the card.
Concession first, then the turn, then three short faults. The grade drops a full letter from the winner with no arithmetic shown (scores with no method).
Planned for ours, before we wrote: kept the move. CS-P1's rival cards open the same way: a tagline that grants the strength and names the catch, plus three numeric bars. Our rivals are astaxanthin softgels at the 12 mg serving, never liver formulas. Already has. b7b9
See these lines on their page ↗#35at 48%●●●○○h2 · 5× p · 46 words
Five pros, generously worded: formulated by a specialist doctor, an absorbable milk thistle, a complete vitamin E, the same 90-day guarantee as the winner, a certified US plant.
Why it works. Earn the right to criticise by praising first and in detail. candorborrowed-authority
Why it sits here, and how it is written
Pros come before cons on every card: the reader sees fairness before judgment. Naming the rival's branded ingredients shows the reviewer read the label.
The technical names are explained in the same breath, so they read as expertise, not jargon. Five pros is the most any rival gets; the count falls with rank.
Planned for ours, before we wrote: kept the move. CS-P1 gives each rival three true pros read from its own product page on a dated day. Same move, already there. Keep the accuracy rule: no invented defects, no praise we cannot verify.
See these lines on their page ↗#36at 50%●●●●○h2 · 4× p · 51 words
Four cons, each a checkable fact: twice the daily capsules of the winner, $49 or more a bottle, exact amounts printed on the label but not the sales page, and the best price tied to a recurring order.
Why it works. Mark the runner-up down on convenience, price and openness without saying it does not work. contrastspecificityloss-aversion
Why it sits here, and how it is written
After the praise, so each fault reads as a fair observation. Two of the four name the winner in the comparison, which keeps the top card in mind while the reader is inside another product's card.
Every con can be verified on the rival's site. The third is the weakest: the amounts are on the label, so the fault is only where they are printed. The subscription point is the one that stings.
Planned for ours, before we wrote: kept the move. CS-P1 marks rivals down the same way: softgels per day to reach 12 mg, no batch report to open, cost per day. It rarely names CellScience inside a rival's card. Naming ours in one con per card is the piece to add. One softgel a day and a one-time purchase are ours. b9b7c3
See these lines on their page ↗#37at 52%●●○○○h3 · 2× p · 84 words
The verdict praises first (a specialist's formula pairing two ingredients made for better uptake, placing it in front of nearly every rival), then lists where it trails the winner: capsule count, amounts missing from the sales page, price.
Why it works. Repeat the card in prose for the reader who skips lists. candorcontrast
Why it sits here, and how it is written
Prose follows lists on every card. The second paragraph opens by naming the winner, so the comparison is explicit at the moment the reader might be tempted by the runner-up.
The second paragraph is one long sentence of three clauses, each a repeat of a con above. Nothing new is said; the repetition is the method.
Planned for ours, before we wrote: kept the move. CS-P1's rival cards carry two paragraphs in this order: what it gets right, then the catch. Already has. Ours stay on facts read from the rival's own page.
See these lines on their page ↗#38at 55%●●●○○h3 · p · 47 words
The bottom line calls it the best of the four alternatives for someone who wants a doctor's formula, then repeats the three costs of choosing it.
Why it works. Say who should still buy the rival, which proves the list is not a hit piece. candoridentificationloss-aversion
Why it sits here, and how it is written
Ending each card on who the product suits keeps the reviewer's neutral pose to the last line. For the runner-up it matters most: a fair second place makes first place believable.
It closes on a spoken warning formula, friend to friend. It is the third pass over the same three faults inside one card, and by now it drags.
Planned for ours, before we wrote: kept the move. CS-P1 ends each rival card with a price tier and a short verdict tag. It has no sentence on who should still buy the rival. Worth adding, one line per card: it costs nothing and reads as fairness.
See these lines on their page ↗Ours, word for word
#2 · rival card
2 Rank
Astaxanthin Softgels (bag)
Rovina Astaxanthin 12mg
The one you have seen in ads. Natural astaxanthin in coconut oil, with a catch on the label: four softgels a day to reach 12 mg.
12 mg in one softgel
5.0 / 10
Third-party lab tested
6.0 / 10
Cost per day
4.0 / 10
Rovina gets the source right. Its astaxanthin comes from the same microalgae ours does, and it sits in organic coconut oil. The bag is resealable and the guarantee is a generous 90 days.
Then read the directions. Two softgels in the morning and two in the evening. That is four a day to reach the 12 mg serving, and a bag of 60 lasts 15 days. The brand says every batch is third-party tested; the results are available on request rather than posted. At the price we saw, a month is two bags.
✓ Pros
- Natural astaxanthin from microalgae, in organic coconut oil
- 90-day money-back guarantee
- Made in a GMP-certified, FDA-registered facility
✗ Cons
- Four softgels a day, morning and evening, to reach 12 mg
- A 60-softgel bag is a 15-day supply
- Batch test results on request, not posted
$$$$ · four softgels a day The right source, the wrong routine
Proposed change 1 · Rival cards: the order waits on your verdict
On the rankings you kept, a rival's place matches its scores. Ours puts the lowest-scoring product second, and BioAstin's text says it earns the second spot while it sits third. A reader who checks the bars sees the list disagree with itself.
Order the four rivals by our own three scores: #2 Sports Research · #3 BioAstin · #4 Dr. Mercola · #5 Rovina. BioAstin's sentence becomes two: “BioAstin has been on shelves longer than anyone here. It earns third place on the label alone.”
Proposed change 8 · Rovina card: who it suits waits on your verdict
Same move: the card ends on who should still buy it.
Last line of the card: “Who it suits: the buyer who wants the 90-day guarantee, and does not mind four softgels a day.”