← MGI Clinic workspace
Rendered from video-studio/scripts/mgi/COPYCHIEF-r1.md

Copy chief — MGI Clinic video scripts 01–04, round 1 (2026-10-28)

House framework (skills/copychief-house/SKILL.md): the Truth Gate and BRAND.md rules win; a lever the owner has ruled out gets the strongest line inside the ruling; compliance is the officer's separate pass (CL-00); every fix must be sayable. Judged on conversion only. Fixes are applied as round 2 the same day; round 1 is archived in _r1/.

Piece classification

Four cold-prospecting video scripts for Meta, 70–80 seconds at the render's pace, each a founder-to-camera piece for one real presenter (Dr. Chanu Dasari) except 04, a run-of-show for a real patient. Awareness: solution-aware (01–03), problem-aware (04). Offer: a $50 fifteen-minute call the surgeon makes himself. Modelled on the structures of the rival David watches (CCL-STUDY.md). Audience: people with a bowel diagnosis who have been given the same two options in every office.

Big picture

What works. The structures are the right ones: the diagnosis-for-life open, the five unasked questions, the fire and the wood, the question that is his page's own hook, the call as a judgement on your case. Every proof is a Truth Gate id. The register is spoken: contractions, one thought into the next, the label counted on a hand. The three David-watched devices are all here: a real person on a phone, the patient who did everything right, the one thing missed named in seconds.

Where it stops singing.

  1. Length. 71, 78 and 70 seconds for three founder pieces whose rival runs 41–56 seconds on its newest ads. The playbook says cut beats, never squeeze words. In each script one beat repeats something an earlier beat already did: 01's proof beat restates the solution beat; 02's solution beat re-introduces him after the hook already placed him at nineteen; 03's story beat re-introduces him after the hook already said medical school. Each script can lose a beat and keep every proof.
  2. The felt moment is missing. The rival's ads say the body out loud (blood, urgency, the bathroom map, the semester off). 01 and 03 never do; 02 does once ("plan the day around a bathroom"). The buyer the taste log describes plans the day around a bathroom; one sentence of that in 01 and 03, in his mouth about patients, is the difference between a doctor explaining and a doctor who knows.
  3. "Pick a time at the link. I'll call you." is right and short, but three scripts end on the identical sentence and the CTA never names the format in the last line (CL-03: name the format). "Fifteen minutes on the phone" belongs in the close, not only in the middle.
  4. The question beat in 02 carries three sentences and the full-screen super; it is the best moment in the set and it is buried at 30 seconds behind two agitation beats. Move the second agitation (the fire and the wood) after the question so the question lands at 21s, where the rival lands its turn.
  5. 04's windows. The render holds each captured slot for its seconds plus a beat; the piece reads 115 seconds. The slots are right for a 45-second cut once the editor has the footage, but the script should say so: the captured seconds are ceilings.

Line level

LocationIssueFixPrinciple
01 · hook"At nineteen a doctor told me it was for life. The plan was steroids, then biologics." — good; "for life" is softer than what he was told"At nineteen a doctor told me it was for life, it was genetic, and the plan was steroids, then biologics."The hook carries the whole villain (v1) in one breath.
01 · story 1"Lifelong, genetic, and nothing I ate would matter. That's what I was told." repeats the hook"Before any of that I was nineteen, with IBD, sitting in an office, being told that nothing I ate would matter."Say the big idea once.
01 · story 2"became the surgeon who sees these guts from the inside" — "these guts" is a pointer"became the surgeon who looks at inflamed bowels from the inside, through a scope"Name the noun.
01 · turnstrong; add the bodyafter "I ask every patient.": "Because by the time someone plans the day around a bathroom, five things have been feeding the fire for years."The body said out loud; the fire image shared across the set.
01 · solution + prooftwo beats say one thingone beat: "So I take the call myself. Fifteen minutes on the phone, fifty dollars, and I'm the one calling. No tests to sell you, no supplements to sell you. I go through what you've tried and tell you plainly what I'd do next."Cut the beat, keep every proof (o1, o2, p3).
01 · cta"Pick a time at the link. I'll call you.""Pick a time at the link. Fifteen minutes on the phone, and I'll call you."Name the format (CL-03).
02 · hook"Every office since has said the same two words." — "two words" is a riddle the listener can't solve"Every office since has offered the same two roads."The noun is the roads (steroids, biologics), named a sentence earlier.
02 · agitation 1"Five things. In ten years of appointments, not one question about any of them." — goodkeep—
02 · orderthe question (turn) sits behind two agitations at 30sturn moves to beat 3; the fire-and-wood beat becomes beat 4 and ends on "…still plan the day around a bathroom."The best line lands at 21s, where the rival lands its turn.
02 · solution"That's the call. I'm Dr. Chanu Dasari, a GI and colorectal surgeon, and I was that patient at nineteen." re-introduces him"That's the call. Fifteen minutes, fifty dollars, and I'm the one calling: Dr. Chanu Dasari, a GI and colorectal surgeon, and the patient in that office at nineteen."One introduction, inside the offer, in his cadence.
02 · benefit + cta"If you think one of those five is feeding the fire, that's what the call is for." + the stock closekeep the bridge; close "Pick a time at the link. Fifteen minutes on the phone, and I'll call you."The belief bridge is the rival's best device; keep it whole.
03 · hookhis own hooks-reel line; strongkeepHis words.
03 · story"I'm Dr. Chanu Dasari, a GI and colorectal surgeon, and a former IBD patient. Seventy to eighty percent of the immune system sits in the gut lining. So let me draw where the trouble starts." — the intro delays the drawing"Seventy to eighty percent of the immune system sits in the gut lining. So let me draw where the trouble starts. I'm Dr. Chanu Dasari. I'm a gut surgeon, and at nineteen I was the patient."The drawing starts by second eight; the intro rides on it.
03 · solution25 seconds, one beat; the five are counted but the body never appearssplit: beat 3 = one and two (diet, digestion); beat 4 = three, four, five, then "Five suppliers. The appointments I sat through as a patient asked about none of them, and I was planning my days around a bathroom."Split a bloated beat; say the body.
03 · turn"I don't tell anyone to turn a medicine down. I work on the wood, with daily coaching, and no tests or supplements to sell." — three claims in one breath"I don't tell anyone to turn a medicine down. I work on the wood." (daily coaching and no-tests move to the proof beat)One thought per sentence.
03 · proof"On the call I go through your case against these five and tell you which one I'd start with. Fifteen minutes, fifty dollars, and I'm the one calling."add: "No tests to sell you, no supplements to sell you."The proof beat carries p3; the turn stays clean.
03 · ctathe stock close"Pick a time at the link. Fifteen minutes on the phone, and I'll call you."CL-03.
04 · turn"The first thing I asked wasn't about the next drug." — "the next drug" reads as anti-medication to a nervous reader"The first thing I asked wasn't about a prescription. It was what they ate, how they digested it, how they slept, the stress, whether they moved."The owner's rule: never anti-medication, not even by contrast.
04 · solutionfinekeep—
04 · slotsthe captured seconds read as fixed lengthseach marker says "up to"; a production note says the four slots are ceilings for a 45–60-second cutThe render holds them; the editor cuts them.

Verdict

Top three changes: (1) cut the repeated beat in 01, 02 and 03 and name the format in every close; (2) say the body once in 01 and 03; (3) move 02's question to beat three.

Kill list: 01 proof beat as a separate beat; 02's "the same two words"; 03's three-claim turn; 04's "the next drug".

For the officer (never a verdict, CL-00): "remission" appears only inside the question (q1); "inflammation" and "autoimmune" are descriptive; the 70-to-80-percent line is Dr. Dasari's own on his channel; no timeline, count or outcome is stated anywhere.

Status (round 2 applied the same day)

Fixes appliedall rows above, as round 2 (Register rows marked)
Archive_r1/ + email/mgi/video-scripts-audio/r1/
Gatesre-rendered with --retime; audit ALL PASS
Boardthe version board, round 1 beside round 2, on the review page