← CellScience workspace
Rendered from prelanders/mgi/quiz-case/COPYCHIEF-r1.md

MG-P4 · copy chief, round 1 (2026-10-27)

/copychief-house on every customer-facing line of flow.json (v1, unboarded). All eight rewrites are applied: the
gates and the iPhone walk passed afterwards (build_quiz.py quiz-case, tools/qa/mgi_quiz_check.py --quiz quiz-case).
Judged on conversion only (CL-00). The owner's word binds:
- Dr. Dasari's bans: cure, fix, heal, reverse, guarantee, refund, free, "mechanism".
- Remission only as a question.
- Never "instead of medication".
- The Truth Gate.

Piece Classification

second carries the PubMed screenshot). The result is a case card, the first of his five causes he'd look at, the next two, then the call.

not met a gut surgeon who was the patient, or the five causes he works on.

care you already have. The quiz is the story; the result is his first read of it.

Big Picture Assessment

  1. Hook. Each of the three opening lines is a 👍 from David's hook-buckets round, so all three are already chiefed:

All three pass both tests. "Oh yeah, what does it do?": instant recognition, then a question. Believability: a real patient says it. The problem was fit: a and c speak as the patient, and the deck spoke as Dr. Dasari ("I was diagnosed…") with no change of voice between them. Two "I"s in a row means the reader has to stop and work out who is talking. Fixed: a and c in quote marks, and the deck now opens "I'm Dr. Chanu Dasari."

  1. Lead. Quiz leads live or die on the button. "TELL ME YOUR STORY" was on-concept but named the work. Fixed: the

button now names the payoff.

  1. Reason why.

Enough for a $50 call. The cap is the pictures: his photos at 19 and now, his hand drawing the gut, and the man on the call are all gray boxes. They are the evidence David's watches reward.

  1. Offer. "$50 · 15 minutes · I call you myself" is the strongest line on the page. No risk reversal is possible

(guarantee and refund are banned), and none is needed at $50 when the man himself calls. The case card adds a reason to book now: "Bring your card."

  1. Close. The booking button sits at the top and the bottom. The close ties the card to the call. No fake urgency, and

none needed.

  1. Emotional throughline.

No sag. The one gap was the doctor question. It lacked the brush-off patients quote most (VoC; MG-A12): fixed.

Line-Level Review

#LocationIssueFix (applied)Principle
1Start · title a / c + deckPatient voice, then doctor voice, with no seam. Who is "I"?a and c in quote marks; deck: "I'm Dr. Chanu Dasari. I was diagnosed with IBD at 19, and now I'm a gut surgeon. Tell me your story in 10 questions, and I'll show you where I'd start in your case."One voice per line. Never make the reader work out who's talking.
2Start · button "TELL ME YOUR STORY"Names the effort (telling, being vulnerable) instead of the payoff."SHOW ME WHERE YOU'D START"The CTA states what they get (Makepeace: sell the result, not the process).
3Q1 "First, what did they call it?""They" has no referent on screen one."First, what did your doctors call it?"Specificity: name the actor.
4Q3 "How many days does your gut decide your plans?""How many days" asks for a count; the options are frequencies."How often does your gut decide your plans?"Question and options must match, or the reader hesitates.
5Q6 optionsThe question is the emotional core but missed the dismissal patients quote most: "it's just stress" (VoC; angle MG-A12; the rival David watches, Trust Your Gut, wins on "this is not your fault").Added "“It's just stress.”", with its echo: "You were told it's just stress. Stress is real. It's one of the five causes I work on. “Just” is the word I'd argue with." Also "“Let's try a biologic,” or the next one" (it was two sentences).Enter the conversation already in their head (Collier). The answer they'd give is the one you list.
6Echo · surgery "…so I know that conversation from both sides"Truth. It implies he faced surgery as a patient, and nothing on record says so."Surgery is on the table. I'm a GI and colorectal surgeon, and I was the patient at 19. Before you decide anything, let's talk."Truth Gate (CL-01) first. The true version is just as strong.
7Email sub "Want where I'd start by email, too?" · guide_offer "Want where I'd start by email?""Want where…" can't be said out loud without a stumble.Sub: "I can email you where I'd start, and what I'd look at in each. Where should I send it?" · offer: "Get a copy by email".Write like you talk; if you stumble, they will.
8Card foot "It's what I'd want in front of me on the call"Logic slip: the screenshot is on their phone, not his desk."Take a screenshot and have it in front of you on the call. It's everything I'd ask first."Every sentence must be literally true, or the reader feels the seam.
9Exercise card "Movement is one of the five causes I work on."Telling, flat, and the only cause block without a picture in the reader's head."Movement is the cause a flare takes from you first."Experienced benefit over stated feature.
10Echo · between doctors "Then you're who this call is for"Awkward construction."This call was made for you: fifteen minutes with a gut surgeon who was the patient first."Read it out loud.

Checked and kept:

is listening to me".

The Verdict

With real photos (and the 30-second selfie for the start screen), this is a 9.

  1. Name the speaker after a patient-voice opening.
  2. Add "it's just stress" with its answer.
  3. Make the start button name the payoff.

lines, and "what I'd want in front of me". Nothing else drags.

For Chanu pass 2 (NOTES.md):