MG-P4 · copy chief, round 1 (2026-10-27)
/copychief-houseon every customer-facing line offlow.json(v1, unboarded). All eight rewrites are applied: the
gates and the iPhone walk passed afterwards (build_quiz.py quiz-case,tools/qa/mgi_quiz_check.py --quiz quiz-case).
Judged on conversion only (CL-00). The owner's word binds:
- Dr. Dasari's bans: cure, fix, heal, reverse, guarantee, refund, free, "mechanism".
- Remission only as a question.
- Never "instead of medication".
- The Truth Gate.
Piece Classification
- Type: a quiz prelander. Framework #2, Doctor's Investigation. It has 10 questions and two notes from Dr. Dasari (the
second carries the PubMed screenshot). The result is a case card, the first of his five causes he'd look at, the next two, then the call.
- Funnel position: cold Meta traffic (layer 1) → the $50 discovery call (book.mgiclinic.com).
- Market:
- Adults with Crohn's, colitis or IBD, or told it's IBS, mostly 40+.
- On mesalamine, prednisone or a biologic, and still planning the day around a bathroom.
- Told "it's mild", "your labs look fine" or "it's just stress".
- Awareness: problem-aware to solution-aware (Schwartz 2–3). They know the disease and its standard treatment. They have
not met a gut surgeon who was the patient, or the five causes he works on.
- Big idea: the surgeon who was the patient at 19 hears your whole story and tells you where he'd start, alongside the
care you already have. The quiz is the story; the result is his first read of it.
Big Picture Assessment
- Hook. Each of the three opening lines is a 👍 from David's hook-buckets round, so all three are already chiefed:
- a · "The bathroom-finder app sits on my home screen. Next to weather."
- b · "The medicine calms the fire. Something keeps adding wood."
- c · "My biologic costs more than my car payment. Nobody asked about breakfast."
All three pass both tests. "Oh yeah, what does it do?": instant recognition, then a question. Believability: a real patient says it. The problem was fit: a and c speak as the patient, and the deck spoke as Dr. Dasari ("I was diagnosed…") with no change of voice between them. Two "I"s in a row means the reader has to stop and work out who is talking. Fixed: a and c in quote marks, and the deck now opens "I'm Dr. Chanu Dasari."
- Lead. Quiz leads live or die on the button. "TELL ME YOUR STORY" was on-concept but named the work. Fixed: the
button now names the payoff.
- Reason why.
- His story: IBD at 19, well for over ten years on diet and lifestyle, then the surgeon.
- The five causes.
- One clean study: stress, 2.4 times the odds of a flare, for Crohn's and colitis both.
Enough for a $50 call. The cap is the pictures: his photos at 19 and now, his hand drawing the gut, and the man on the call are all gray boxes. They are the evidence David's watches reward.
- Offer. "$50 · 15 minutes · I call you myself" is the strongest line on the page. No risk reversal is possible
(guarantee and refund are banned), and none is needed at $50 when the man himself calls. The case card adds a reason to book now: "Bring your card."
- Close. The booking button sits at the top and the bottom. The close ties the card to the call. No fake urgency, and
none needed.
- Emotional throughline.
- Recognition (the opening).
- Confession ("Which of these is your life right now?").
- The emotional peak: "What did your doctor say the last time?"
- Him: "I've been on both sides."
- The reframe: "Your gut… panics before you do."
- The future: "what would you do first?"
- Being heard: the card, an echo that answers his doctor's line, "I'm listening."
No sag. The one gap was the doctor question. It lacked the brush-off patients quote most (VoC; MG-A12): fixed.
Line-Level Review
| # | Location | Issue | Fix (applied) | Principle |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Start · title a / c + deck | Patient voice, then doctor voice, with no seam. Who is "I"? | a and c in quote marks; deck: "I'm Dr. Chanu Dasari. I was diagnosed with IBD at 19, and now I'm a gut surgeon. Tell me your story in 10 questions, and I'll show you where I'd start in your case." | One voice per line. Never make the reader work out who's talking. |
| 2 | Start · button "TELL ME YOUR STORY" | Names the effort (telling, being vulnerable) instead of the payoff. | "SHOW ME WHERE YOU'D START" | The CTA states what they get (Makepeace: sell the result, not the process). |
| 3 | Q1 "First, what did they call it?" | "They" has no referent on screen one. | "First, what did your doctors call it?" | Specificity: name the actor. |
| 4 | Q3 "How many days does your gut decide your plans?" | "How many days" asks for a count; the options are frequencies. | "How often does your gut decide your plans?" | Question and options must match, or the reader hesitates. |
| 5 | Q6 options | The question is the emotional core but missed the dismissal patients quote most: "it's just stress" (VoC; angle MG-A12; the rival David watches, Trust Your Gut, wins on "this is not your fault"). | Added "“It's just stress.”", with its echo: "You were told it's just stress. Stress is real. It's one of the five causes I work on. “Just” is the word I'd argue with." Also "“Let's try a biologic,” or the next one" (it was two sentences). | Enter the conversation already in their head (Collier). The answer they'd give is the one you list. |
| 6 | Echo · surgery "…so I know that conversation from both sides" | Truth. It implies he faced surgery as a patient, and nothing on record says so. | "Surgery is on the table. I'm a GI and colorectal surgeon, and I was the patient at 19. Before you decide anything, let's talk." | Truth Gate (CL-01) first. The true version is just as strong. |
| 7 | Email sub "Want where I'd start by email, too?" · guide_offer "Want where I'd start by email?" | "Want where…" can't be said out loud without a stumble. | Sub: "I can email you where I'd start, and what I'd look at in each. Where should I send it?" · offer: "Get a copy by email". | Write like you talk; if you stumble, they will. |
| 8 | Card foot "It's what I'd want in front of me on the call" | Logic slip: the screenshot is on their phone, not his desk. | "Take a screenshot and have it in front of you on the call. It's everything I'd ask first." | Every sentence must be literally true, or the reader feels the seam. |
| 9 | Exercise card "Movement is one of the five causes I work on." | Telling, flat, and the only cause block without a picture in the reader's head. | "Movement is the cause a flare takes from you first." | Experienced benefit over stated feature. |
| 10 | Echo · between doctors "Then you're who this call is for" | Awkward construction. | "This call was made for you: fifteen minutes with a gut surgeon who was the patient first." | Read it out loud. |
Checked and kept:
- "I know the tests, the prescriptions and the bathroom math." The body said out loud; the best line on the page.
- "I'm not judging it. I'm looking for what's been tried on you, and what nobody has looked at yet." Never anti-medication.
- "Waiting to see if it gets worse is not a plan."
- "Labs are one part of the picture. The rest is what you just told me."
- "I won't tell you to turn it down. I'll tell you what nobody has looked at alongside it." Chanu pass 2 must OK this stance.
- "Your gut has its own nervous system. It panics before you do." David's 👍 line, now the stress note's title.
- "I was the patient at 19. I know what it's like to tell your story and not be heard. I'm listening." VoC: "I feel like no one
is listening to me".
The Verdict
- Conversion readiness: 8/10. Capped by the three gray boxes:
- his photos at 19 and now;
- his hand drawing the gut;
- him on a call.
With real photos (and the 30-second selfie for the start screen), this is a 9.
- Top 3 high-impact changes (done):
- Name the speaker after a patient-voice opening.
- Add "it's just stress" with its answer.
- Make the start button name the payoff.
- What's working:
- The structure: confession, then being heard, then the call.
- The doctor question and its six echoes. Each answers what their doctor said in his voice, without attacking medicine.
- The case card: their own words back, bulleted, private.
- "Where I'd start" as one named thing, not three causes at once.
- The specific body lines: bathroom math, safe foods, close calls.
- Kill list: done. "Movement is one of the five causes I work on.", "Then you're who this call is for", both "Want where…"
lines, and "what I'd want in front of me". Nothing else drags.
For Chanu pass 2 (NOTES.md):
- "I won't tell you to turn it down" (his stance on biologics).
- "I managed it with diet and lifestyle and stayed well for over ten years."
- The six echoes.
- His photos.