COPYCHIEF — Lansil Global supplier price check, the headline and subheadline (hero round 1, 2026-11-09)
David: "lets copy-chief these 2 headline and subheadline".
- H1: "Pay 20% less than your supplier."
- Sub: "If your supplier isn't the factory, you're paying a middleman's markup. Paste a product you sell, and we show our price from the factory, 20% under what you pay."
Both are David's own copy rule (2026-10-26). He opened them for review today, so this round judges them like any other line and keeps the H1 as the control.
What still binds:
- No "Alibaba" or "AliExpress" anywhere on the page.
- The 20% stays: it is exactly what the tool computes.
- The Truth Gate: no fixed company numbers (x3), no "only" (x1), no invented proof (x7).
- Never the M-word (CL-02).
- Compliance is not this pass (CL-00).
This round supersedes round 1's S8 (the sub's second sentence). Approve a row here and S8 is treated as DENY.
Piece Classification
- Type: the hero of an interactive lead tool. The H1 and sub sit above a three-field form ("Find my price").
- Funnel position: cold to warm: the site, email, and later search ads for supplier, sourcing and factory-price intent.
- Target market: an ecommerce operator importing from China. Solution-aware about suppliers, unaware of their supplier's margin. Most believe the supplier they found IS the factory.
- Angle: LG-A04, the middleman between your factory and your customer.
- Lansil hook taste (
briefs/lansilglobal/angles/TASTE.md): "the question they already ask" is 6 for 6, "the split" 4 for 4, "the number that shouldn't exist" 3 for 3. "Us-vs-them" lines win.
Big Picture Assessment
The H1 is a strong control and a safe line.
- "Pay 20% less than your supplier." has a number, an enemy the reader pays every month, and a payoff, in six words. It matches the tool to the cent: the page later says "20% under what you pay".
- It passes the bar stool: a sourcing agent says exactly this across a table.
- On the first hook test ("oh yeah, what does it do?") it half-fires. The reader wants the how, but the line itself is the most common shape a discount promise takes.
- On believability, the cold reader flinches: "you don't even know my supplier."
- That is "too good but not great": competent, on-angle, forgettable next to every other sourcing agent's "save on your sourcing". It earns the control slot, and the twenty weirder lines below are the real search.
The sub has the right villain and gives every reader a way out.
- "If your supplier isn't the factory" lets everyone who believes their supplier is the factory (most of them) read on with "not me". The middleman line should plant the doubt, not hand out the exit.
- The Truth Gate holds no figure for how many suppliers are middlemen, so the doubt has to come from "might" or a question, not a statistic.
- The second sentence is the form's instructions said twice. "Paste a product" (it's a link), "we show our price from the factory" (soft), and a second "20%" the H1 already said.
- It never says how fast, and "in about a minute" is true: the lookup takes 10–15 seconds after the sign-up.
Line-Level Review
H1 · "Pay 20% less than your supplier."
- Issue: right promise, generic shape. It is the offer bucket; the doubt that makes it believable lives only in the sub.
- Fix: keep it as the control (row B1). Test it against a headline that makes them doubt their supplier first: B2 "Is your supplier really the factory?", or the weird row W1 "Your supplier has a supplier."
- Principle: lead with the reader's own question (Lansil's best device, 6 for 6). The promise follows the doubt.
Sub, sentence 1 · "If your supplier isn't the factory, you're paying a middleman's markup."
- Issue: "If" opens the door to "not me". "A middleman's markup" is abstract: once, how much, on what?
- Fix: "Your supplier might not be the factory, and you pay their markup on every unit."
- Principle: plant the doubt, don't offer the exit. "On every unit" turns a one-off into a cost that repeats on every reorder.
Sub, sentence 2 · "Paste a product you sell, and we show our price from the factory, 20% under what you pay."
- Issue: it is mechanical, repeats the H1's 20%, says "product" where it means link, and gives no time.
- Fix: "Paste a product link and see the factory price in about a minute."
- When the H1 has no 20% in it, the sub carries the number: "…and our price, 20% under what you pay."
- Principle: the action, how fast, and the payoff, once.
The chief's pair (row B1):
- H1: "Pay 20% less than your supplier."
- Sub: "Your supplier might not be the factory, and you pay their markup on every unit. Paste a product link and see the factory price in about a minute."
The batch: eight pairs, one per lane
Each row is a headline with the sub that goes with it, named by bucket and device. The argument bucket is used once (B7).
| Row | Bucket · device | Headline | Sub |
|---|---|---|---|
| B1 | competitor attack · the number (the control) | Pay 20% less than your supplier. | Your supplier might not be the factory, and you pay their markup on every unit. Paste a product link and see the factory price in about a minute. |
| B2 | competitor attack · the question they already ask | Is your supplier really the factory? | Paste the link to a product you sell. In about a minute you'll see what factories quote for it, and our price, 20% under what you pay. |
| B3 | timing & usage · stop / don't | Don't reorder until you've seen the factory price. | If your supplier isn't the factory, every reorder pays their markup again. Paste a product link and see the factory quotes, and our price, 20% under what you pay. |
| B4 | location · the object out of place | What your product really costs in China. | Paste the link to a product you sell. You'll see what factories in China quote for it, and our price, 20% under what you pay. |
| B5 | competitor attack · us vs them | See what the factory charges for your product. | If your supplier isn't the factory, the gap is their markup. Paste a product link and see the factory quotes, and our price, 20% under what you pay. |
| B6 | competitor attack · the split | Same product. Your supplier's price, or 20% less. | We buy direct in Shenzhen, so the middleman's markup comes off. Paste a product link and see your price in about a minute. |
| B7 | the argument (the one) | We buy direct in Shenzhen. You pay 20% less. | No middleman between you and the factory. Paste the link to a product you sell and see your price in about a minute. |
| B8 | long-term fears · the receipt | Every reorder pays your supplier's markup again. | Unless your supplier is the factory. Paste a product link and see what factories quote for it, and our price, 20% under what you pay. |
The weird twenty (headlines; the sub follows whichever wins)
These are two rungs past comfortable, built on unique situations rather than categories. Each still passes both tests and the Truth Gate. The default sub for any of them: "Paste the link to a product you sell. In about a minute you'll see what factories quote for it, and our price, 20% under what you pay."
| Row | Bucket | Headline |
|---|---|---|
| W1 | competitor attack | Your supplier has a supplier. |
| W2 | micro-human moment (the pause before the reply) | Ask your supplier for the factory's address. Watch how long the reply takes. |
| W3 | competitor attack · the number that shouldn't exist | Your product has two prices. You've only ever seen one. |
| W4 | competitor attack · the split | Same product. Same factory. A different invoice. |
| W5 | reverse / skeptic | Your supplier isn't lying. They're just not the factory. |
| W6 | location | Somewhere in China, your product costs 20% less. |
| W7 | environmental (the office you're paying for) | Part of every unit you buy pays a middleman's rent. |
| W8 | location · competitor attack | Made in China. Marked up in between. |
| W9 | micro-human moment (the doubt) | Has your supplier ever seen your product being made? |
| W10 | timing & usage | Before you reorder 5,000 units, paste one link. |
| W11 | competitor attack | Your unit cost has a stranger's margin in it. |
| W12 | location · the argument | The factory price is one phone call in Chinese away. We make the call. |
| W13 | offer | Your best-seller, minus the middleman. |
| W14 | the split | One link. Two prices. Ours is the lower one. |
| W15 | offer | Put the middleman's cut back in your margin. |
| W16 | long-term fears (absurd, filmable) | Last year, your markup paid for someone else's new car. |
| W17 | micro-human moment (the photo) | Those factory photos your supplier sent. Whose factory is it? |
| W18 | competitor attack · exposé | Find out what your supplier won't tell you. |
| W19 | competitor attack (the rule of thumb) | If they won't name the factory, they're not the factory. |
| W20 | long-term fears | The 20% you're missing is on someone else's invoice. |
The Verdict
- Conversion readiness: H1 7/10, sub 6/10, the pair 6.5/10. With the chief's sub (B1) the pair is 7.5/10. The upside past 8 is a headline that makes them doubt their supplier before it makes a promise (B2, W1, W3, W19).
- Top 3 high-impact changes
- Turn the "if" into planted doubt, at a cost that repeats: "Your supplier might not be the factory, and you pay their markup on every unit."
- Make the second sentence the action, the time and the payoff, once: "Paste a product link and see the factory price in about a minute."
- Test a doubt-first headline against the control. My pick is W1 "Your supplier has a supplier." with the B1 sub: four words, it fires the first hook test on contact, and it is true of every trading company.
- What's working: the number in the H1 matches the tool to the cent. The enemy is one the reader pays every month. The imperative "Pay" puts them in the action. The middleman is the right villain for LG-A04.
- Kill list
- "If" as the sub's first word.
- "Paste a product" (it's a link).
- The second "20%" in the sub when the H1 already says it.
- "our price from the factory".